06 August 2016

Is it better to stay on a job for years or job hopping?

This is one question I always ask myself whether which one is more beneficial in long terms if one would to stay on for a job for many years or job hopping every 2-3 years. Before we discuss on this topic, let us do a comparison on the Pros and Cons between these two.

Pros for staying a job for many years
Leadership or Competent - If you are competent and have good leadership skills, your boss will always give you the opportunities to lead the team to run a new project.
Seniority - If you stay at a company for the long haul, you will be more likely to rise in seniority, rather than having to start from scratch and fight to establish a stronger role in the company.
Stability - If you are constantly worrying about where you will be in the next year, it is very difficult to make long term plans. A little stability in your career or workplace can help you to cope more effectively with the stresses that are sure to happen in your life.
Flexibility - Most people who stay in a company for many years, progress through multiple challenging roles when they are in the company. They are typically trying many roles to help them to determine what they are most passionate on. They get to retain their status and benefits and also free to experiment new areas.

Cons for staying a job for many years
Taking for granted - When you are in the company for many years, you have the tendency to take things for granted. You think that you can set the rules and everyone had to follow suit which does not align the company's policies or directions.
Stagnant Increment - Your annual increment is not as great as you joined a new company. Your annual increment would probably be around 2-3% as compared to 10-20% if you choose to job hopped.
No more passionate - When things had became a routine, you no longer have any passionate in your work nor do you find any motivational drive in pushing yourself in the next career milestone.

Pros for job hopping
More money - When you job hop, you will always ask for a salary increment of 10-20%. You do not change a job if it is of the same as your current or lower unless you want a change in your job roles to undertake lower responsibility.
New environment - A change in new working environment entices you to be more motivated to learn new things and more passionate in contributing in the new company. It give you the opportunity to experience new company's culture and the way how the company run their businesses. You are expanding your network to a new pool of professionals.

Cons for job hopping
Employers will be hesitant to invest in you - When jumping from job to job, you are showing future employers that there is a high likelihood that you will do the same to them. By putting in the number of years working with them proves your loyalty as well as strengthening your job security. Loyalty goes a long way and from the employers perspective, it gives them the dependability that they can count on.
Your job maybe less secure - If your employer is forced to retrench staffs, you might be the first to go given your track record of job hopping.
Loss of seniority - When you joined a new company, you have to start afresh and build your career in the new company. Everything had to start from zero to build your way up in the corporate ladder.

I had been with my current company for coming to 2 years. A new startup and a new industry that the company is venturing with. It is always good to be a pioneer in a new startup with the company. You get to try everything under the sun and your words tend to be more heard than the juniors joining the company. A very good 2 years with the company and team bonding with fellow colleagues. But however, the company does not pay well in rewarding the staffs. A typical employee gets an annual increment of 2-3% and promotion will only come probably 3-4 years in your stay with the company. The increment for the promotion is only about 5-8%.

With the continuous rising standard of living in Singapore and inflation, the increment does not help to sustain the rising cost. The question to ask oneself is whether should we change a higher salary job to meet the inflation and also to increase our income to eventually be financial freedom. There are too many considerations one need to consider to stay put in the company or job hop. There is no right or wrong answer. Ultimately you have to ask yourself when you made this decision, are you comfortable with it?

To me, if I am a fresh graduate that just embarked in this new journey. I will focus on my areas of work and gain more experiences before I job hop. Then I can command better salary package with the number of years of experiences. If I am in the peak in my career, I would probably choose to stay put. Firstly, age is consideration when you choose to job hop. A company would not be keen to invest on you as you are already of certain experiences and you commanded a higher salary if the company employ you. Secondly, once you hit a certain amount of salary cap, the company will try to slow down your salary by giving you lower increment. In a way, they are favoritism in new graduates by giving them more increment. If old timer like you or me are not happy, the door is always open for you to move out.

A guideline below on what I think you should stay put or job hop based on your age. By looking at the table tells you the prime time to job hop is between 26 to 40 years old. Anyone above 40 years old, it is best that you stay put with the company for your own good. This is based on my opinion, readers may beg to differ.

AgeDecision
20-25Stay put
26-30Stay put / Job hop
31-35Stay put / Job hop
36-40Stay put / Job hop
41-45Stay put
46-50Stay put

6 comments:

  1. A good comparison of job hopping vs staying on the job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi there, I have the same thoughts around this job hopping vs sticking in the same job for the past few weeks and I am having a headache about it. I am currently in my role for two years; stable place and no firing but manual processes, unfriendly team mates, demanding boss. Pay rise every year is 2-3% and take 3-5 years for promotion. I have been on the job look out and I am likely to get an offer (gone for final round of interview) soon. However the job at new company the company isn't as stable and I am just worried that after I move to this new company economy gets worse and my job gets retrenched. As you mentioned job hopping isn't a good thing and shows very badly on resume. Which is why I am feeling very troubled. My past few years of employment history has been 1 year each. Longest was 3 years. Anyway just sharing my thoughts (or rather sharing my problems) here. Not sure whether to take a leap of faith. Current situation at company is unhappy though I try hard to be positive..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi CY,

      Thanks for reading my blog. Looking at your situation, your past few years of employment has been 1 year each, which is not very good in the eyes of new employers. Of course, if the new employer is willing to engage your service since you mention you had gone for final round of interview. You should joined them if the salary package and benefits are better than your current company. If the new company that you are going to join is an establish company, I do not see why you shouldn't join them if you are worried about the market outlook in the next few years. Lastly, if you are still young, I feel you should move on and experience more new things in other companies if you do not have any family commitment to hold you back.

      Delete
  3. Hi Eric, thanks for your advice. I am working in the banking industry and in recent years many functions have been deployed to lower cost locations to India hence the past few jobs which I spent one year each was due to the said deployment, except for my first job where I spent 3 years there. I am currently in a bank which is very stable as its operations are in Singapore and won't deploy functions out to other countries. Though work environment is very slow paced and culture is toxic which is the main reason why I am moving out. The potential job in the other bank is slightly less stable as it is a global bank with operations everywhere and has deployed bulk of the functions already so considered 'stable' in that sense. But as cost cutting is main pressure by banks, banks will continue to deploy still. So I am just worried that if thIs new role is made redundant within the next 2 years I would need to find a new job. To be honest, I am very tired of going for interviews and explaining reasons for leaving. But Current job has come to the point where Everyday I am dragging myself to work and don't feel like I am learning much. Let's see what the potential offer provide in term of salary... Venting my problems here ;)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for reading my blog. I believed you are not the only one facing this kind of situation. Many industries had been shifting their operations to oversea to cut down on labour cost. Hence it is inevitable for us if we are working in the company that run operations. The only thing that we can do is either to value-add to the company or totally changed of field that we work in. As times goes by, your worth will be lesser if you do not upgrade your skill-sets, you will be easily replaced by another foreign talent that is cheaper than you and more skillful. You do not want to be caught in a situation whereby you are not able to find a job when you have family commitment.

      Delete
    2. Yeah agreed upgrading skill sets is important. I think building a wealth machine is even more important than being reliant on a fixed salary every month. That is the few ways we can be entirely free of being at the mercy of the bosses and the employers

      Delete